Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to footer
Back to Tour Chicago Blog

Pirate Stories of Lake Michigan

The Great Lakes have a rich history of shipwrecks, storms, and tales of adventures. Among the more colorful chapters of this history are the legends and stories surrounding pirates of Lake Michigan. While the Caribbean is commonly associated with the swashbuckling pirates of yore, the fresh waters of Lake Michigan have their own tales of plunder and treachery.

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Lake Michigan saw a boom in shipping and commerce. Lumber, grains, and other goods were shipped across its waters. This surge in shipping naturally attracted those who saw opportunity in less-than-honorable pursuits.

One of the most infamous pirates on Lake Michigan was “Roaring” Dan Seavey. Seavey was unlike the stereotypical pirates of the ocean; he was a former sailor and fisherman who turned to piracy in the early 1900s. His reasons for turning rogue are varied. Some say it was due to economic hardship, while others believe it was simply the thrill of lawlessness.

Seavey’s tactics were quia close up of a boat next to a body of waterte ingenious. He would light lanterns on the shoreline to confuse ships and make them believe they were approaching a safe harbor. When the ships ran aground due to these deceptive lights, Seavey and his crew would plunder their cargo. His reign of terror was so well-known that many stories attribute various shipwrecks and disappearances on the lake to him, even if there’s no evidence of his involvement.

Another tale involves James Jesse Strang, the self-proclaimed “King of Beaver Island.” While not a pirate in the traditional sense, Strang was a charismatic leader of a breakaway Mormon faction. He declared himself king of Beaver Island in Lake Michigan and established a rather autocratic rule. Under his leadership, there were whispers of piracy, as the island’s residents were often accused of raiding passing ships and harboring stolen goods.

As with any good legends, the line between fact and fiction often blurs. There’s the tale of the “Lake Michigan Triangle,” a region in the lake known for mysterious disappearances of ships, reminiscent of the Bermuda Triangle. Some attribute these disappearances to natural phenomena, while others believe pirates used the triangle as a cover for their dastardly deeds.

Besides these notable characters, live story telling sailstories abound of hidden treasures buried along the shores of the lake. Legends tell of pirates burying their loot on remote islands or secluded beaches, waiting for a time when it’s safe to return. These stories have led many an adventurer to search for the hidden treasures of Lake Michigan.

Despite the legends and lore, it’s essential to remember that Lake Michigan’s “pirates” operated in a very different context than their Caribbean counterparts. The vastness of the Great Lakes, combined with the many ports, hiding spots, and secluded coves, made it a haven for those seeking to escape the law or turn a quick profit.

In the end, while Lake Michigan might not have seen the likes of Blackbeard or Captain Kidd, its pirate tales are a fascinating chapter in the region’s history. These stories remind us that the allure of piracy, with its promise of quick riches and a life outside the law, is not confined to the high seas. The freshwater expanses of the Great Lakes have their own legends, filled with characters and tales that continue to captivate and intrigue.

From $69 per Person

Sail into the night and embark on a two-hour party sail from Navy Pier; join us for Chicago’s only Pirates Pub. Sail onboard a 148-foot Tall Ship in the Windy City! This popular Chicago event is one you will not want to miss; it is unlike all other boat excursions in Chicago. Enjoy an onboard DJ and the wind in your hair as you dance the night away with the mesmerizing Chicago skyline as your backdrop. Sing along to traditional pirate tunes and your favorite party anthems while soaking in the breathtaking sights on Lake Michigan.